How to be a Conservative
Conservative Ideology for Contemporary Times
Book Edition Details
Summary
In a world where conservatism is often cast aside as relics of the past, Sir Roger Scruton steps boldly into the fray with a narrative both provocative and poignant. "How to Be a Conservative" serves not merely as a manifesto but as an impassioned plea for the enduring values that underpin our civilization. Scruton, with his characteristic wit and intellectual rigor, challenges the zeitgeist dominated by left-liberal ideologies, offering instead a roadmap to a life enriched by traditional principles. Through his own life as a public intellectual and counter-cultural figure, he explores the vitality and necessity of conservatism, arguing that while society might persist without it, true human flourishing demands its presence. This book is a clarion call for those seeking depth and dignity in a world eager to forget its roots.
Introduction
Modern political discourse often reduces conservatism to mere resistance to change or blind adherence to outdated traditions. This superficial understanding overlooks conservatism's sophisticated philosophical foundation and its unique capacity to address contemporary challenges through accumulated wisdom rather than revolutionary schemes. The conservative worldview emerges not from reactionary impulses but from a profound understanding of how human societies actually function, flourish, and maintain themselves across generations. The intellectual framework presented here challenges prevailing assumptions about political progress, social engineering, and the role of tradition in modern life. Rather than dismissing conservative thought as antiquated, this exploration reveals how conservative principles offer practical solutions to persistent human problems while preserving the delicate social fabric that enables individual freedom and collective flourishing. The analysis demonstrates how conservative insights transcend partisan politics to address fundamental questions about human nature, social organization, and the proper relationship between individual liberty and communal responsibility. Through systematic examination of core conservative principles, this work invites readers to reconsider their assumptions about progress, tradition, and the sources of social stability. The journey ahead requires intellectual honesty about both the achievements and limitations of modern liberal democracy while maintaining faith in humanity's capacity for gradual improvement through tested institutions and practices.
The Conservative Foundation: Tradition, Civil Society, and Human Nature
Conservative philosophy rests on several foundational insights about human nature and social organization that distinguish it from both revolutionary socialism and abstract liberalism. At its core, conservatism recognizes that human beings are not isolated rational actors making contracts in a vacuum, but deeply social creatures whose identity and capacity for moral action emerge through relationships, traditions, and inherited institutions. This understanding shapes every aspect of conservative political thought. The concept of civil society occupies central importance in conservative thinking. Unlike enterprise associations formed for specific goals, civil associations develop organically from human sociability and provide intrinsic rather than instrumental value to their participants. These associations - families, churches, voluntary organizations, local communities - create the social capital that makes both individual freedom and collective action possible. They transmit values, skills, and knowledge across generations while fostering the habits of cooperation and mutual responsibility essential to democratic governance. Tradition functions not as dead weight from the past but as accumulated social wisdom embedded in customs, institutions, and practices. These traditions represent solutions to recurring human problems, tested through experience and refined over time. They contain knowledge that cannot be easily articulated or replaced by rational planning because they encode the complex adjustments necessary for human cooperation. To destroy traditions carelessly is to discard hard-won social learning and risk social fragmentation. The conservative understanding of human nature acknowledges both human potential and human limitations. People are capable of moral growth and rational choice, but they are also prone to error, self-deception, and the corrupting effects of unchecked power. This dual recognition leads conservatives to favor institutional arrangements that channel human ambition toward constructive ends while providing checks against its destructive potential. The result is a political philosophy that seeks gradual improvement through tested means rather than radical transformation through untested theories.
Finding Truth in Modern Political Movements: Nationalism to Environmentalism
Each major political movement contains elements of truth wrapped within potentially dangerous excesses. Conservative analysis seeks to extract these valuable insights while avoiding the ideological extremes that transform legitimate concerns into destructive fanaticism. This approach allows conservatives to learn from their opponents while maintaining critical distance from totalizing worldviews. Nationalism contains the essential truth that democratic governance requires a "we" - a shared identity that makes political compromise possible and gives meaning to citizenship. Without this pre-political bond, politics degenerates into mere interest-group competition or factional warfare. The nation provides a territorial and cultural framework within which diverse individuals can participate in common political life while maintaining their particular loyalties and beliefs. However, nationalism becomes dangerous when it treats the nation as the ultimate source of value or when it seeks to impose cultural uniformity through state power. Socialism correctly identifies the reality of mutual dependence in modern societies and the moral obligation to share the benefits of social cooperation with those who contribute to but cannot fully capture its rewards. The socialist insight about exploitation and inequality addresses genuine injustices that conservatives must acknowledge. However, socialism becomes destructive when it reduces all social relations to class warfare or when it assumes that state control can replace the complex mechanisms through which civil society generates and distributes social goods. Liberalism offers the crucial insight that individual rights and limited government are necessary conditions for human flourishing in diverse societies. The liberal emphasis on tolerance, due process, and constitutional constraints protects minorities and dissidents from majority tyranny. Yet liberalism becomes problematic when it treats individual choice as the supreme value or when it attempts to dissolve all traditional sources of authority and meaning in the name of personal autonomy. The challenge for conservatives is to preserve liberal protections while maintaining the social bonds that make freedom meaningful and sustainable.
The Realms of Value: Religion, Beauty, and Cultural Inheritance
Beyond material concerns and political arrangements lie realms of intrinsic value that give meaning and purpose to human life. Conservative philosophy recognizes that societies cannot survive on utilitarian calculations alone but require shared sources of transcendent meaning that inspire sacrifice, commitment, and mutual care. These realms of value emerge through human association but cannot be manufactured through political programs. Religious traditions provide perhaps the most powerful source of transcendent meaning, offering frameworks for understanding human purpose, moral obligation, and ultimate questions about existence. Even in increasingly secular societies, religious inheritance continues to shape moral intuitions, cultural practices, and social institutions. Conservative appreciation for religion stems not necessarily from personal faith but from recognition that religious traditions preserve wisdom about human nature and social life that purely secular approaches often neglect. The challenge lies in maintaining space for religious expression while avoiding theocratic impositions on those who do not share particular beliefs. Beauty represents another realm of intrinsic value that enriches human experience and connects individuals to larger patterns of meaning. Aesthetic experience provides moments of harmony and transcendence that lift human consciousness above immediate practical concerns. The built environment, artistic traditions, and natural landscapes all contribute to the cultivation of aesthetic sensibility and the sense of being at home in the world. Conservative cultural policy seeks to preserve and transmit these aesthetic achievements while resisting the iconoclastic impulses that would destroy inherited beauty in the name of equality or progress. Cultural inheritance encompasses the accumulated artistic, intellectual, and moral achievements that define civilizations and provide resources for addressing contemporary challenges. This inheritance includes not only great works of art and literature but also the skills, practices, and forms of knowledge that enable communities to flourish across generations. Conservative education aims to transmit this inheritance while adapting it to contemporary needs, recognizing that cultural traditions remain vital only through creative appropriation by each new generation.
Conservative Practice: Defending Freedom Through Institutional Wisdom
Conservative theory finds its practical expression in the defense and cultivation of institutions that protect freedom while fostering social cohesion. These institutions operate through informal norms and formal structures that have evolved to address recurring human challenges. Conservative practice involves strengthening these institutions against both external threats and internal decay while adapting them to changing circumstances. The family serves as the fundamental institution for transmitting values, providing care, and creating the bonds of loyalty and responsibility that extend outward to larger social commitments. Conservative family policy seeks to support rather than direct family formation, recognizing that healthy families emerge from the choices and commitments of their members rather than from state programs. This support includes economic policies that make family formation feasible and cultural policies that honor rather than undermine familial commitments. Educational institutions provide the primary means through which societies transmit knowledge, skills, and cultural inheritance to new generations. Conservative educational philosophy emphasizes the importance of objective knowledge, rigorous standards, and respect for intellectual tradition while avoiding both progressive indoctrination and reactionary dogmatism. The goal is to equip students with the tools for independent thinking while connecting them to the accumulated wisdom of their civilization. Local governance and civil associations provide the intermediate institutions between family and state that enable democratic participation while fostering civic virtue. These institutions allow individuals to exercise responsibility, develop leadership skills, and address common problems through voluntary cooperation. Conservative political practice seeks to strengthen rather than supplant these institutions, recognizing that centralized bureaucracy cannot replace the local knowledge and social capital they generate.
Summary
The conservative vision emerges as a sophisticated response to the eternal human challenge of creating and maintaining social order that enables both individual flourishing and collective achievement. Rather than offering utopian promises or revolutionary solutions, conservatism provides a framework for gradual improvement through the cultivation of proven institutions and practices. Its strength lies not in rigid ideology but in flexible wisdom that adapts enduring principles to changing circumstances while maintaining continuity with the past and responsibility to the future. This approach offers particular value to those seeking alternatives to both uncritical progressivism and reactionary nostalgia, providing a path for thoughtful engagement with contemporary challenges through time-tested means.
Related Books
Download PDF & EPUB
To save this Black List summary for later, download the free PDF and EPUB. You can print it out, or read offline at your convenience.
By Roger Scruton
