Playing to Win
How Strategy Really Works
byA.G. Lafley, Roger L. Martin
Book Edition Details
Summary
In the realm of corporate strategy, where victory often eludes the unprepared, former Procter & Gamble CEO A.G. Lafley and strategic adviser Roger Martin present a masterstroke in "Playing to Win." This isn't just another business manual; it's an invitation to revolutionize your approach with the Five Choices Framework. By drawing on their transformative work at P&G, where they astoundingly amplified sales and profits, Lafley and Martin illuminate the path to true competitive dominance. The book unravels how strategic decisions—crafted with precision and vision—can catapult companies from mediocrity to market leadership. With vivid case studies of household names like Olay and Gillette, this guide offers an unmissable blueprint for leaders determined to transcend mere participation and secure their place as champions in the marketplace.
Introduction
In today's fiercely competitive business landscape, countless organizations struggle not because they lack talent or resources, but because they fail to make the crucial strategic choices that separate winners from survivors. Every day, leaders face complex decisions about where to compete, how to differentiate, and what capabilities to build. Yet many drift through these decisions without a clear framework, hoping that hard work alone will somehow translate into market leadership. The reality is that winning requires more than effort—it demands deliberate, integrated choices that create sustainable competitive advantage. This journey through strategic thinking will equip you with the tools and mindset to transform uncertainty into opportunity, helping you craft strategies that don't just compete, but dominate in your chosen markets.
Define Your Winning Aspiration and Playing Field
Strategy begins with a fundamental question that most organizations struggle to answer clearly: what does winning actually look like for us? Too many companies confuse activity with achievement, mistaking revenue growth or market participation for true victory. A winning aspiration serves as your North Star, providing the clarity needed to make every subsequent strategic choice with purpose and precision. Consider the transformation that occurred when Olay faced a critical crossroads. The skincare brand had become synonymous with an aging customer base, earning the unfortunate nickname "Oil of Old Lady." Sales had stagnated below $800 million annually, while younger consumers consistently chose more relevant alternatives. The brand faced a stark choice: accept gradual decline or reinvent itself completely. Rather than simply hoping for better days, the leadership team made a bold decision to redefine what winning meant for Olay. The transformation began with a clear winning aspiration: become the leading age-defying skincare brand for women entering their prime concern years, those aged 35-49 who were just beginning to notice the first signs of aging. This wasn't merely about market share—it was about owning a specific moment in women's lives when they transition from basic skincare to serious anti-aging regimens. The team committed to reaching $1 billion in sales while establishing an entirely new market segment that bridged mass and prestige skincare. To define your own winning aspiration, start by identifying the specific customer need you're uniquely positioned to fulfill. Ask yourself: if we disappeared tomorrow, what would customers genuinely miss that they couldn't find elsewhere? Next, quantify what success looks like in concrete terms—revenue targets, market position, or customer outcomes. Finally, ensure your aspiration inspires action by making it ambitious enough to require strategic choices yet achievable enough to maintain credibility. Your winning aspiration should energize your team while providing clear decision-making criteria. When faced with opportunities or challenges, you should be able to ask: does this move us closer to or further from our winning aspiration? This clarity transforms strategy from abstract planning into focused execution.
Build Competitive Advantage Through Strategic Capabilities
Once you've defined winning, the next crucial decision involves determining where to compete and how to create unassailable competitive advantage. This isn't about being everywhere for everyone—it's about choosing your battles wisely and building capabilities that competitors cannot easily replicate. The most successful organizations create what strategists call "activity systems"—interconnected capabilities that reinforce each other and become increasingly difficult to copy. Olay's transformation illustrates this principle beautifully. Rather than competing head-to-head with established prestige brands in department stores, the team chose to create an entirely new battlefield. They decided to compete in mass retail channels—drugstores, supermarkets, and discount retailers—but with prestige-quality products and premium pricing. This "masstige" strategy required building capabilities across multiple dimensions simultaneously. The innovation team developed breakthrough formulations using ingredients previously reserved for high-end department store brands, creating products that could genuinely compete on efficacy. The marketing team crafted sophisticated campaigns that appeared in the same magazines and television shows as luxury competitors, elevating Olay's brand perception. Perhaps most critically, the pricing strategy team discovered through extensive testing that $18.99 represented a sweet spot—expensive enough to signal premium quality to prestige shoppers, yet not so expensive as to alienate mass market customers. To build your own competitive advantage, identify the 3-5 core capabilities that must work in harmony to deliver your unique value proposition. These might include deep customer understanding, rapid innovation, operational excellence, or strategic partnerships. The key is ensuring these capabilities reinforce each other rather than operating in isolation. A breakthrough product means little without the marketing capability to communicate its benefits or the operational capability to deliver consistently. Focus your investment on capabilities that create the biggest gap between you and competitors. Remember, competitive advantage isn't about being good at everything—it's about being distinctively superior at the things that matter most to your chosen customers. The goal is creating a system so interconnected and sophisticated that competitors cannot replicate it without rebuilding their entire approach.
Create Systems That Support Strategic Excellence
Even the most brilliant strategy fails without robust management systems to support and sustain your strategic choices. These systems serve as the connective tissue that transforms individual decisions into organizational capabilities, ensuring that your strategy becomes embedded in how your organization actually operates rather than remaining an abstract plan gathering dust. The challenge many organizations face was perfectly captured in one executive's description of traditional strategy meetings as "corporate theater at its best." Teams would prepare elaborate presentations, anticipating every possible question, with the primary goal being survival rather than strategic advancement. This defensive approach created a culture where real strategic issues were buried under layers of data and political maneuvering. The transformation began with a radical shift in how strategic conversations occurred. Instead of formal presentations to large audiences, strategy reviews became intimate working sessions focused on just 2-3 critical strategic questions identified in advance. Participants were limited to bringing no more than three pages of new material, forcing focus on genuine strategic thinking rather than comprehensive analysis. The goal wasn't to sell a perfect plan but to engage in productive dialogue that would strengthen the strategy through collective insight. This new approach fundamentally changed the quality of strategic thinking throughout the organization. Leaders began approaching strategy reviews as opportunities to tap into collective wisdom rather than defend predetermined positions. The famous phrase became: "I have a view worth hearing, but I may be missing something." This balance of advocacy with inquiry created space for breakthrough thinking while maintaining individual accountability. To implement similar systems in your organization, start by redesigning how you discuss strategy. Replace presentation-heavy meetings with working sessions focused on specific strategic questions. Create measurement systems that track progress against your strategic choices, not just financial outcomes. Most importantly, establish communication norms that reward strategic thinking and collaborative problem-solving over political positioning. Remember that management systems must evolve with your strategy. As your competitive landscape shifts and your organization grows, the systems that once supported your success may become obstacles to future advancement. Regularly assess whether your systems are enabling or constraining your strategic ambitions, and be prepared to redesign them as needed.
Summary
True strategic success emerges not from perfect plans but from making better choices more consistently than your competitors. As this exploration has revealed, winning requires the courage to define what victory looks like, the wisdom to choose battles you can win, and the discipline to build supporting systems that sustain your advantage over time. The most powerful insight may be this fundamental truth: "Strategy is choice—more specifically, strategy is an integrated set of choices that uniquely positions the firm in its industry so as to create sustainable advantage and superior value relative to the competition." Your next step is deceptively simple yet profoundly challenging: gather your team, define your winning aspiration, and begin making the strategic choices that will separate your organization from those content merely to participate rather than dominate in their chosen markets.
Related Books
Download PDF & EPUB
To save this Black List summary for later, download the free PDF and EPUB. You can print it out, or read offline at your convenience.
By A.G. Lafley
