Picasso's War
How Modern Art Came to America
Book Edition Details
Summary
Amidst the tumult of a world teetering on the brink of war, a peculiar alchemy unfolded that would forever reshape the landscape of modern art. Enter the daring John Quinn, an Irish American lawyer with an audacious dream to amass a legendary Picasso collection, and the visionary Alfred H. Barr, Jr., the young trailblazer at New York's fledgling Museum of Modern Art. Their paths entwine in a saga bursting with intrigue, ambition, and resistance, as they strive to usher Picasso's daring works across the Atlantic. Against the backdrop of Hitler's loathsome crusade against "degenerate art," their alliance with the imperiled dealer Paul Rosenberg catalyzes a pivotal exhibition. Hugh Eakin's "Picasso’s War" unfurls the extraordinary tale of how a singular display not only cemented Picasso's legacy in America but also safeguarded avant-garde masterpieces from Nazi grasp, shifting the art world's epicenter from Paris to New York in a breathtaking cultural coup.
Introduction
In the early decades of the twentieth century, a quiet but fierce cultural battle was being waged across the Atlantic. While European artists were revolutionizing the very foundations of visual expression through Cubism, Surrealism, and abstract art, America remained largely hostile to these radical experiments. The story of how modern art finally crossed the ocean and took root in American soil reveals one of the most remarkable cultural transformations in history, driven by unlikely heroes, devastating wars, and the sheer force of artistic vision. This narrative illuminates three profound questions that continue to shape our cultural landscape today. First, how do societies overcome their resistance to revolutionary ideas, particularly when those ideas challenge fundamental assumptions about beauty, meaning, and tradition? The fierce battles over Picasso's paintings and Duchamp's sculptures were never merely aesthetic disputes—they were proxy wars over America's readiness to embrace the complexities of modernity itself. Second, what role do individual visionaries play in preserving cultural movements when institutions fail them? The story demonstrates how a handful of determined collectors, dealers, and museum pioneers could alter the course of art history through sheer conviction and strategic thinking. Finally, how do global crises and political upheavals reshape the flow of cultural ideas across national boundaries? Two world wars, economic depression, and the rise of fascism all played crucial roles in determining which artworks survived, where they found sanctuary, and how they ultimately conquered new audiences. This account will resonate with anyone interested in the intersection of art, politics, and social change, as well as those curious about how cultural institutions are born and evolve under pressure. It offers particular insights for museum professionals, collectors, and cultural leaders grappling with questions of artistic value and public education that remain remarkably relevant in our own era of rapid cultural transformation.
The Pioneer's Vision: Quinn and Early Modern Art (1911-1924)
The transformation of American artistic taste began with a single explosive moment in February 1913, when the International Exhibition of Modern Art opened at the 69th Regiment Armory in New York. Among the bewildered crowds confronting Picasso's fractured faces and Matisse's wild colors stood John Quinn, an Irish-American corporate lawyer whose life would be forever changed by what he witnessed. While critics denounced the works as "degenerate" and visitors laughed at Duchamp's "Nude Descending a Staircase," Quinn recognized something revolutionary: art that captured the energy and complexity of modern life itself. Quinn's response was characteristically bold and systematic. Rather than simply collecting fashionable pieces, he embarked on an unprecedented campaign to acquire the most important works by leading avant-garde artists. Working through Henri-Pierre Roché, a charming French intermediary who moved effortlessly through Parisian artistic circles, Quinn built direct relationships with artists like Picasso, Braque, and Matisse. His apartment on Central Park West became a shrine to modernism, filled with paintings that most Americans found incomprehensible or offensive. The resistance Quinn faced revealed deep cultural anxieties about America's place in the rapidly changing world. American critics viewed European modernism as a foreign infection that threatened national values and artistic traditions. When the Metropolitan Museum attempted a modest post-Impressionist exhibition in 1921, it sparked fierce controversy, with religious leaders denouncing the "moral degeneracy" of modern art and politicians questioning the patriotism of those who promoted it. Quinn found himself defending not just aesthetic choices, but fundamental questions about cultural freedom and artistic expression. Yet Quinn's vision extended far beyond personal collecting. He dreamed of creating a modern museum that would educate Americans about contemporary art and establish New York as a rival to Paris. His systematic approach to building a collection—seeking the defining masterpieces of each major movement—provided a template for future museum builders. Though Quinn died in 1924 before realizing his institutional ambitions, his collection had planted the seeds of a cultural revolution that would eventually transform American taste and establish the foundation for what would become the Museum of Modern Art.
Building the Bridge: Barr's Museum and European Connections (1929-1939)
The dispersal of John Quinn's collection after his death sent shockwaves through America's small community of modern art enthusiasts, highlighting the painful absence of institutional infrastructure to support contemporary art. This crisis galvanized a new generation of cultural leaders, including three determined women—Lillie Bliss, Abby Aldrich Rockefeller, and Mary Sullivan—who resolved to create the museum Quinn had envisioned. Their choice of director proved inspired: Alfred Barr, a young Harvard-trained art historian who brought both scholarly rigor and missionary zeal to the task of educating America about modern art. Barr's revolutionary approach transformed how Americans experienced contemporary culture. Unlike traditional museum directors who focused on acquiring prestigious old masters, Barr saw his role as interpreting living artistic movements and explaining their significance to skeptical audiences. His innovative exhibition design—clean white walls, careful lighting, and educational labels—created an entirely new way of encountering art that would influence museums worldwide. His landmark Van Gogh exhibition of 1935 demonstrated this method's power, drawing massive crowds and fundamentally changing American perceptions of an artist previously dismissed as mentally unstable. The museum's relationship with European dealers and collectors became increasingly crucial as political tensions mounted across the Atlantic. Barr cultivated partnerships with figures like Paul Rosenberg, Picasso's primary dealer, who recognized America as a vital new market for modern art. These connections allowed the Museum of Modern Art to mount increasingly ambitious exhibitions, bringing masterpieces to American audiences that had never been seen outside private European collections. Each show became a cultural battleground, with critics and supporters debating not just artistic merit but fundamental questions about art's role in democratic society. The rise of fascism in Europe added new urgency to these debates. As Hitler's regime began its systematic campaign against "degenerate" modern art, Barr recognized that aesthetic questions had become inseparable from political ones. The artists he championed—many Jewish, many explicitly anti-fascist—represented values of individual freedom and creative expression that totalitarian regimes sought to destroy. By the late 1930s, defending modern art had become a form of defending democracy itself, setting the stage for the climactic transformation that would determine whether America would embrace or reject the artistic heritage of European modernism.
War as Catalyst: The Great Exhibition and Exile (1939-1945)
The outbreak of World War II in September 1939 created an unprecedented opportunity that would forever alter the global art world. As German armies swept across Europe, the continent's greatest art collections faced destruction or seizure by Nazi forces. Alfred Barr, recognizing the historical moment, launched his most ambitious project yet: a comprehensive Picasso retrospective that would bring together masterpieces from across Europe just as they were becoming inaccessible to future generations. What began as a temporary exhibition became a permanent migration, as the war made it impossible for European loans to return home. The exhibition's success exceeded all expectations, drawing record crowds and transforming Picasso from a controversial avant-garde figure into a popular cultural icon. More importantly, the extended American tour that followed brought modern art to audiences from Boston to San Francisco, marking a decisive shift in national taste. For the first time, ordinary Americans in cities across the country encountered the full power of European modernism, and their enthusiastic response demonstrated that the cultural ground had shifted beneath the feet of conservative critics. The human drama paralleled the artistic transformation. Paul Rosenberg, Picasso's dealer and one of the most influential figures in the Parisian art world, found himself fleeing Nazi-occupied France with little more than the clothes on his back. His harrowing escape through Spain and Portugal, aided by a heroic Portuguese consul who defied his government's orders, brought him to New York just as American interest in modern art was exploding. The dealer who had spent decades trying to crack the American market suddenly found himself at the center of a cultural revolution he had helped create. The war's end revealed the full scope of the transformation. Paris, once the undisputed capital of the art world, lay in ruins, its galleries closed and its artists scattered. Meanwhile, New York had become home to a remarkable community of European refugees—artists, dealers, critics, and collectors who brought with them the accumulated wisdom of centuries of European cultural development. The city that had once looked to Europe for artistic leadership now found itself inheriting that leadership, along with the responsibility to preserve and extend the modernist tradition. The battle for modern art in America had been won, but victory brought new challenges that would shape the cultural landscape for generations to come.
Summary
The triumph of modern art in America reveals how cultural transformation occurs not through gradual persuasion alone, but through the convergence of individual vision, institutional innovation, and historical crisis. The story demonstrates that a small group of passionate advocates, working across decades and continents, can reshape entire cultural landscapes through persistence, strategic thinking, and the courage to champion unpopular causes when they believe in their fundamental importance. The deeper lesson lies in understanding how global upheavals create unexpected opportunities for cultural change. The two world wars that devastated Europe simultaneously created the conditions for America's artistic coming of age, as crisis forced both artworks and the people who understood them to cross the Atlantic. This pattern suggests that periods of disruption, while painful, often accelerate necessary changes that might otherwise take generations to accomplish, revealing hidden strengths and possibilities that emerge only under pressure. For contemporary cultural leaders, this history offers crucial insights that remain remarkably relevant today. First, building institutional infrastructure proves as important as acquiring individual masterpieces, since lasting change requires permanent repositories that can survive political and economic upheavals. Second, public education and contextual presentation are essential for helping audiences appreciate challenging new forms, as even the most revolutionary art requires skilled interpretation to find its audience. Finally, international networks of relationships become invaluable during times of crisis, suggesting that cultural leaders should cultivate diverse partnerships that transcend national boundaries and can preserve artistic achievements across changing political climates. The story reminds us that cultural progress requires not just artistic genius, but also the dedicated work of collectors, curators, and advocates who bridge the gap between creation and public understanding.
Related Books
Download PDF & EPUB
To save this Black List summary for later, download the free PDF and EPUB. You can print it out, or read offline at your convenience.
By Hugh Eakin
