Trust First
A True Story About the Power of Giving People Second Chances
Book Edition Details
Summary
In the heart of Atlanta's most unforgiving neighborhood, Pastor Bruce Deel faced a dilemma: shut down a struggling church or confront the despair around him. "Trust First" chronicles Deel's audacious choice to embrace radical trust, a decision that sparked the creation of City of Refuge—a transformative haven for the marginalized. Where others saw liabilities, Deel saw potential, offering unyielding belief in the downtrodden. With vivid narratives of redemption, the book unveils how unconditional trust can upend cycles of poverty and hopelessness. This compelling tale of faith and resilience reveals a blueprint for systemic change, proving no soul is beyond saving. Every leader and changemaker should heed its call, as Deel dedicates proceeds to fuel the hope City of Refuge ignites daily.
Introduction
In the heart of Atlanta's most troubled neighborhoods, where abandoned buildings cast long shadows and despair seems to echo from every corner, one man's radical experiment in human compassion began with a simple van full of food and an unwavering belief in second chances. Bruce Deel, a white pastor from rural Virginia, found himself drawn to the forgotten souls of the inner city, armed with nothing more than hot meals and an audacious conviction that every person deserves trust before they've earned it. What started as weekend food distribution quickly evolved into something far more profound: a complete reimagining of how society approaches poverty, addiction, and human redemption. Through two decades of transformative work, Deel discovered that the most powerful tool for healing broken lives wasn't programs or policies, but the revolutionary act of trusting people that others had written off as hopeless. His journey reveals the extraordinary power of radical acceptance, the patience required for true transformation, and the courage needed to see potential where others see only problems. From this unlikely beginning emerged a model of holistic care that would challenge conventional wisdom about helping those in crisis and demonstrate that sometimes the most effective way to change the world is simply to believe in the people everyone else has forgotten.
From Suburban Pastor to Urban Missionary
Bruce Deel's transformation from comfortable suburban pastor to inner-city missionary began not with a divine calling, but with a growing sense of unease about the superficial nature of his charitable work. Leading groups into Atlanta's roughest neighborhoods for weekend food distribution felt hollow, like putting bandages on heart attacks. The people he served averted their eyes, knowing he was a stranger they'd probably never see again, creating an uncomfortable distance that good intentions couldn't bridge. When Deel was temporarily assigned to evaluate a struggling downtown church on the verge of closure, his life took an unexpected turn that would define his next two decades. The pivotal moment came when a woman who had been involved in prostitution for fourteen years walked into his small congregation and asked through tears, "Can you help me get out?" This simple plea opened floodgates as word spread through Atlanta's streets about the white pastor who actually helped. Soon, Deel's sanctuary filled with homeless individuals, drug addicts, and people whose lives were characterized by deep struggle. The offering plate began receiving not just crumpled bills, but bags of crack, syringes, and even weapons from those seeking to make a change. Each surrender was met with raucous cheering from the congregation, transforming the church into a celebration of new beginnings. The weight of responsibility to these people who had given up their crutches and taken his hand forced Deel to confront a crucial question: could he really help them beyond the initial flush of hope? His wife Rhonda provided the answer that would change everything: if they were truly going to impact the city, they had to be in the city, living among the people they claimed to want to transform. This realization led to their radical decision to abandon suburban comfort and move their family of four young daughters into an old church building in one of Atlanta's most dangerous neighborhoods. The transformation from occasional visitor to permanent resident marked the true beginning of Deel's journey from traditional pastor to urban missionary, setting the stage for a revolutionary approach to human restoration.
Creating City of Refuge Through Radical Trust
The concept of radical trust emerged from Deel's first dramatic encounter on the streets, when he witnessed a potentially fatal confrontation between two desperate individuals. Gloria, known for her kindness despite her alcoholism, held a gun pointed at Rufus, a belligerent man with a history of violence and self-destruction. In that moment of crisis, Deel made an instinctive decision that would define his entire philosophy: he stepped between them, gently placed his hand on Gloria's, and asked simply, "You don't really want to do this, do you?" The subtle downward pressure he applied, combined with his calm presence, defused a situation that could have ended in tragedy. This experience taught him that people in crisis often need just a gentle touch and someone who believes in their capacity for good choices. From this foundation, Deel developed what he called "benevolent care" – a judgment-free approach that offered not second chances, but thirtieth chances. Moving his family into the inner-city church building was itself an act of radical trust, demonstrating to the community that his commitment wasn't temporary or conditional. The building became a 24-7 haven where trust flowed in both directions, with formerly homeless individuals babysitting his children and managing storage rooms filled with valuable supplies. This wasn't naivety but a calculated risk based on relationships built through shared meals and genuine conversation, where "respectable" people sat beside those society had discarded. The physical manifestation of this trust took shape in what Deel envisioned as a "One Stop Shop" – a comprehensive facility where people in crisis could access everything they needed for recovery and independence under one roof. When philanthropist Malon Mimms donated a 210,000-square-foot warehouse worth $1.6 million, Deel's vision began to take concrete form. Despite the building's challenges – from rat infestations to frequent break-ins – he saw it as the perfect foundation for creating a beloved community where trust and time could work together to facilitate genuine transformation. The warehouse would become City of Refuge, a place where radical trust wasn't just a philosophy but a lived reality that produced measurable change in hundreds of lives.
Transforming Lives Against All Odds
The true test of radical trust came through individuals like Ryan Marchman, a former gang leader whose life had been shaped by violence from childhood. After escaping an assassination attempt, Ryan found himself at City of Refuge, carrying seventeen years of criminal history and a reputation for brutality that made even seasoned staff members question Deel's decision to welcome him. Despite the risks, Deel not only provided Ryan with housing but gave him master keys to the entire facility – a gesture that shocked his staff but demonstrated the kind of trust Ryan had never experienced. This faith proved transformative, though not without setbacks, including Ryan's temporary return to gang life and a dangerous high-speed chase that could have ended in tragedy. Ryan's transformation illustrates the patience required for genuine change. Years of anger management, counseling, and gradual healing led to breakthrough moments, including a phone call with his abusive stepfather where forgiveness flowed both ways, lifting what Ryan described as "a thousand pounds" from his shoulders. This emotional healing opened doors to practical success: Ryan earned his GED, started his own security company, and reconnected with the daughter he hadn't seen since she was a toddler. His journey from violent criminal to successful businessman and loving father demonstrates that even the most damaged individuals can rebuild their lives when surrounded by consistent trust and support. The story of Stephanie, later renamed Victoria Hope, represents another dimension of transformation. Escaping from a cult where she had been trafficked since age five, she arrived at City of Refuge as one of the most damaged individuals Deel had ever encountered. Her violent outbursts, emotional detachment, and deep mistrust of men made many staff members recommend psychiatric hospitalization. Instead, Deel chose to offer unconditional love and acceptance, believing these were the only medicine for someone who had never experienced genuine care. The breakthrough came during a retreat in Colorado, where Victoria prayed to hear a man say he loved her without wanting something in return – and found Deel waiting with flowers and chocolate when she entered the dining hall, calling it proof that God cared about her. These transformations required not just initial trust but sustained commitment through multiple failures and false starts. Deel learned to celebrate small victories – a day without violence, a moment of gratitude, a week of sobriety – rather than demanding immediate, permanent change. This approach created space for people to grow at their own pace while maintaining the dignity essential to genuine transformation.
The Enduring Power of Love and Acceptance
The ultimate measure of transformation at City of Refuge isn't independence or conventional success, but the ability to extend love and acceptance to others. Many graduates return not just as success stories but as staff members and volunteers, using their experiences to help others navigate similar journeys. Tennie Woods, who deliberately got arrested to escape her drug-dealing life, now works as a security guard protecting women who have escaped sex trafficking. Ryan Marchman operates a security company that specifically hires people with criminal backgrounds, offering them the second chances he once needed. Their stories illustrate how receiving radical trust creates a compulsion to extend it to others. This cycle of transformation extends beyond individual success stories to create a model of community that challenges conventional approaches to social problems. Deel's rejection of the "success-failure" binary in favor of ongoing journeys of becoming allows for realistic expectations while maintaining hope for continued growth. Some residents, like Rufus and Vanessa, may never achieve complete independence but find dignity in contributing what they can while receiving the care they need. Rufus, now nine years sober, delivers weekly envelopes of small bills to support others in need, while Vanessa continues to volunteer despite her physical limitations and ongoing health challenges. The power of this approach lies not in its ability to "save" everyone but in its recognition that everyone deserves to be treated with dignity regardless of their circumstances or potential for change. Deel learned that his role wasn't to be a savior but to create conditions where transformation could occur naturally through relationships built on trust, acceptance, and non-judgmental love. This philosophy attracted volunteers who discovered that serving others became the most satisfying work they'd ever known, creating a sustainable community of care that continues to grow. The enduring legacy of City of Refuge demonstrates that systematic change happens one relationship at a time, built on the foundation of seeing potential where others see problems. Deel's radical trust isn't naive optimism but a practical recognition that human beings flourish when treated with dignity and given genuine opportunities to contribute to their communities. After more than two decades, this approach has created not just individual success stories but a replicable model of hope that challenges society to reconsider how it treats its most vulnerable members.
Summary
Bruce Deel's journey reveals that the most powerful force for human transformation isn't programs, policies, or professional intervention, but the radical act of trusting people before they've proven themselves worthy of that trust. His work at City of Refuge demonstrates that when we approach broken individuals with genuine acceptance and non-judgmental love, we create space for healing that traditional social services often cannot provide. The key insight from Deel's experience is that transformation requires both trust and time – not the quick fixes demanded by funding reports, but the patient commitment to walk alongside people through multiple failures toward eventual wholeness. His approach challenges us to examine our own assumptions about worthiness and redemption, suggesting that the people we're quickest to write off may be the ones most in need of someone who believes in their potential. For anyone working with vulnerable populations or simply trying to live with greater compassion, Deel's story offers a blueprint for seeing past labels and circumstances to the inherent dignity in every human being. His legacy reminds us that sometimes the most effective way to change the world is not through grand gestures or systemic reforms, but through the revolutionary act of extending radical trust to those whom society has forgotten.
Related Books
Download PDF & EPUB
To save this Black List summary for later, download the free PDF and EPUB. You can print it out, or read offline at your convenience.
By Bruce Deel
